| Which IRA is best?
Traditional IRA
(nondeductible)
|
Pros |
Cons |
Is this the right
IRA? |
| Available to everyone under
70-1/2 who has compensation. (Also available
to their spouses.) Tax credit available for
eligible taxpayers (for tax years through 2006
only).
Earnings grow tax-deferred.
Penalty-free withdrawals allowed for first-home
purchase‚ higher education‚ death‚ disability and
certain medical and health insurance bills. |
Contributions are not tax-deductible. Earnings
are taxed as income upon withdrawal.
Withdrawals are calculated pro rata for tax-paid
and tax-due portions‚ which means you cannot take an
early withdrawal without incurring taxes and
possible penalties.
Distributions must begin after age
70-1/2.
Contributions cannot continue after age
70-1/2. |
Consider choosing this IRA when the Roth IRA or
deductible IRA are not possible. Tax-deferred
earnings growth is still an excellent benefit. |
Traditional IRA
(deductible)
|
Pros |
Cons |
Is this the right
IRA? |
| Contributions are tax-deductible. Tax credit
available for eligible taxpayers.
Earnings grow tax-deferred.
Penalty-free withdrawals (same as nondeductible
IRA). |
Distributions are taxed as income. Early
withdrawals incur a penalty tax if no exception
applies.
Contributions cannot be deducted if AGI is too
high.
Belonging to company retirement plan is a factor.
Distributions must begin after age 70-1/2. |
Consider choosing this IRA if: The retirement
tax rate is expected to be substantially lower and
you have a few years before retirement.
The immediate benefit of the tax-deductible
contribution is needed. |
Roth IRA
|
Pros |
Cons |
Is this the right
IRA? |
| Tax credit available for eligible taxpayers.
Earnings grow tax-deferred.
Qualified withdrawals are tax-free.
Withdrawals are taken first from contributions‚
so contributions can be withdrawn at any time tax-
and penalty-free‚ except converted amounts‚ which
must be held at least five years to avoid a 10%
early withdrawal penalty.
Penalty-free withdrawals (same as for traditional
IRA).
Tax-free withdrawals (after five years) for a
first-home purchase.
Age 70-1/2 is not a
factor for contributions or withdrawals. |
Account must “age” five years before earnings
can be withdrawn without incurring taxes and
penalties. Converted amounts must be held a
minimum of five years to avoid a penalty.
Contributions cannot be made if AGI is too high.
Contribution is not deductible on tax return. |
Consider choosing this IRA if you qualify. |
Have an IRA question or need help determining the best IRA for you and your
situation? Contact us today for a complimentary,
no-obligation consultation.
More topics: Back to Individual
Retirement Accounts and IRA Comparison
Chart
|
|

Looking for an answer to a specific financial question? Check
out our learning center or
contact us for a complimentary
consultation.

Are you an Individual? Learn more about
personal
financial planning.

Are you an employer? Learn more about
employee benefit solutions.

Are you a client-driven organization? Learn more about
member solutions.
Are
you a religious organization? Learn more about our
ministry services.
Read
some of our newer financial planning articles and strategies.
"The right and wrong ways
to invest $20,000"
"Now is the time to talk money"
"Money can make us happy"
"Create your own stock
portfolio for less than a night at the movies"
We also have more articles
in our resources area.

Kick$start Your Financial Future Teleseminar!
Hear from three industry experts for 90 engaging minutes of great
financial content for only $15.00.
Read more.
Financial Planning
Insurance Planning
Retirement Panning
Investment Planning
College Education
Planning
Estate Planning
Small Business
Planning
Financial Education
Services |